When stories are contagious, when someone hears a story and picks up with another, it is often not about the same surface topic, but about offering an account of another situation which made the listener feel the same way. 'Next stories' are rapport builders. We feel the same way, we have something in common.
Before the workshop I did this week, I was chatting with someone from facilities who was helping me with last-minute preparations. I was telling him how I'd had a fright the day before, because when I'd rung up to confirm my catering for the room, I'd been told that actually I didn't have the room booked at all. 'My heart stopped,' I told him. Fortunately it turned out I'd just asked about the wrong room, and all was okay.
He picked up on the 'heart stopping' feeling. 'I had one of those yesterday too,' he said. 'I was wandering around John Lewis at lunchtime and thought maybe I ought to start looking for a present for Claire, as her birthday is coming up pretty soon. And then I realised it was today, and she hadn't said anything at all.'
'Oh no!' I said, feeling his pain. Building great rapport here. We have loads in common, right? 'What did you do?' I was looking for the happy ending in his story, like in mine.
But it all fell apart. 'Nothing,' he said. 'I've been looking for a way to get out of it. This way she'll ditch me, and I won't have to do the dirty work.'
Whoa. See what I mean when I carry on about our stories revealing our values? And this one broke the feelings of commonality I'd had with him. Of course we kept chatting, stayed friendly, but for me something had shifted. His story wasn't about what I'd thought it was about. We'd been going in the same direction, and he took it to a place I didn't want to go to.
People feel great when they're swapping stories because it's the feelings they have in common that build the bridges between each one. Finding stories that don't quite resound is uncomfortable, but it is revealing and useful, even if it doesn't build affinity.
